Our Story

Tucked quietly in Wheatley Heights, Bonilla’s Pizza has always been one of those neighborhood secrets you don’t just stumble upon… you’re told about. A true local gem, we've been serving the community with honest, comforting Italian flavors and warm hospitality since day one.

​

What started as a small family-run shop quickly became a go-to spot for those in the know — the kind of place where crispy Grandma Squares, melty mozzarella, and piping-hot slices create loyal regulars and generations of pizza-loving families.

Every pie is made the old-school way: dough mixed fresh daily, sauce simmered in-house, and ingredients chosen like we’re cooking for our own table. No shortcuts, no gimmicks — just quality, care, and that unmistakable neighborhood soul.

We believe great pizza brings people together, whether it’s a cozy family dinner, a quick lunch, a school celebration, or a late-night craving worth the drive.

If you know us, you know. And if this is your first time… welcome to your new favorite spot.